New generation, same quirkiness at the beloved Peninsula mainstay

Buck’s new patio (formerly known as the parking lot) is now open for outdoor dining. (Photo by Magali Gauthier)

After nearly three decades at the helm of the irreverent Buck’s of Woodside, owners Jamis and Margaret MacNiven hav retired and turned the restaurant over to their three sons.

The younger generation reopened the Woodside restaurant last week for outdoor dining and takeout, with a new patio in the parking lot and a new menu.

“We’re happily passing the crown to the boys,” said Jamis MacNiven, who with his wife Margaret opened Buck’s in 1990. “They have a good view of the future.”

The MacNiven sons: Tyler, far left, Rowan, center left, and Dylan, center right, in front of Buck’s with Tyler’s son, Aden, and the restaurant’s head chef, August Schuchman, far right, in Woodside on July 31, 2020. (Photo by Magali Gauthier)

Dylan MacNiven said his parents had been debating this future since closing in March when shelter in place took effect. They had many family meetings to discuss how to best reopen Buck’s — whose dining room, decorated floor to ceiling with artwork and funky collectibles, is the heart of the restaurant but cannot legally serve customers right now — amidst constantly changing public health mandates.

“They’ve been running Buck’s for almost 30 years and there was probably retirement on the horizon anyway,” Dylan said of his parents. “When we were offered to do an outdoor dining area in the front … it seemed like a really good opportunity to at least provide something for the town.”

Jamis MacNiven, longtime owner of Buck’s, pictured in the fall of 2019. Check out the full Q&A we did with him this past November. (Photo By Sammy Dallal)

Over the years, Buck’s became a one-of-a-kind community institution that drew generations of children and families as well as Silicon Valley entrepreneurs, heads of state and famous actors. Jamis MacNiven was known for writing the cheeky menu descriptions and a quarterly travel column that sounded fabricated but was more often than not true.

In late May, before Buck’s had reopened, Jamis MacNiven said they was thinking about turning the restaurant over to their children — Dylan, Tyler and Rowan — with “an eye toward the 21st century.”

“Much of Buck’s is about the past,” he wrote in an email at the time, “but we see that an update at some point is necessary.”

The sons, who grew up working at Buck’s, operate four restaurants in San Francisco. Tyler also co-founded Sun Basket, a popular meal delivery service.

Tyler MacNiven said they want to modernize Buck’s while still “preserving the integrity of the specialness of Buck’s.”

“We watched babies on their second, third day of life come in and watched some of our regulars on the second or third last day of life. That’s been the true magic of Buck’s. It’s a place where life can be experienced,” he said. “My brothers and I are pretty keen on keeping that aspect of it alive.”

Socially distanced lunch at Buck’s in Woodside. (Photo by Magali Gauthier)

Dylan said they’re not trying to recreate the “old Buck’s” outside and that the pandemic required a new style of service and pared down menu. Buck’s now serves smashburgers, with options for plant-based Impossible Meats and vegan cheese, fish tacos, two salads, milkshakes and beer and wine. They plan to add more items soon, including breakfast. August Schuchman, the executive chef for the sons’ San Francisco restaurants, is overseeing the menu revamp.

Diners can eat in the parking-lot-turned-patio created with wooden tables and chairs, plants and some of the interior decor, including the Statue of Liberty that pre-pandemic greeted customers inside the front door holding not a torch but a dripping ice cream sundae (she’s now wearing a mask).

A piece of Buck’s history, updated to reflect current times. (Photo by Magali Gauthier)

Since reopening, they’ve been able to bring back about 12 of Buck’s 45 staff members.

Dylan said they hope the outdoor patio will sustain the restaurant through the summer and fall while they wait for indoor dining to be allowed again. Long term, they’re thinking about “how to move Buck’s into the next phase of its life,” he said, which will require a balance between updating the longtime community favorite and maintaining its unique feel.

“We’re from a different generation. There’s a lot of experience and things that we would bring back as far as our style of service and culinarily,” Dylan said. “Buck’s has such a unique look — it’s not like we’re looking to just paint the walls white and remove all the art.”

In fact, they plan to continue their father’s tradition of collecting unconventional art to decorate the dining room, Tyler said — as well as having their young children work at the restaurant.

He summed it up succinctly: “Buck’s will never die.”

Buck’s is open daily from noon to 8 p.m. and until 9 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. // 3062 Woodside Road, Woodside; (650) 851–8010

Stay up to date with other coverage from The Six Fifty by subscribing to our weekly newsletter, featuring event listings, reviews and articles showcasing the best that the Peninsula has to offer. Sign up here!

Elena Kadvany

A writer with a passion for investigative reporting, telling untold stories and public-service journalism, I have built my career covering education and restaurants in the Bay Area. My blog and biweekly newsletter, Peninsula Foodist, is the go-to source for restaurant news in Silicon Valley. My work has been published in The Guardian, Eater, Bon Appetit’s Healthyish, SF Weekly and The Six Fifty.

You May Also Like

The 12 best views on the SF Peninsula and how to see them

Downtown Menlo Park

Cheese, wine and ‘the best gelato’: French-inspired outdoor market opens in Menlo Park

Data driven: How a Menlo Park teen champion is turning NASCAR into a science

The most epic day hike in Pacifica